CanWest Global Communications
Corp. has grown from humble origins in western Canada to
dominate the Canadian communications landscape.
Over a quarter-century, Global TV has expanded into a third
network that reaches coast to coast. With the acquisition
in 2000 of the Southam group of newspapers (including 14
major metropolitan dailies and the National Post) from
Conrad Black's Hollinger Corp., CanWest has focused on horizontal
and vertical integration — the buzzword is convergence — of
previously distinct media outlets.
Material from its newspapers (all but the struggling
Post spun off in
2005 as CanWest MediaWorks Income Fund) and stations also fuels the canada.com web portal
that functions as a multi-tier subscription service.
An intermittent series of auctions, promoted through
CanWest's other media holdings, are yet another source
of revenue.
CanWest aims to be one of the largest media companies
in North America but its ambitions are, indeed, Global.
It has significant television and radio properties
in Australia and New Zealand and in 2005 started buying
radio stations in Turkey. In August 2006, CanWest
sold its stake in TV3, a private network in the Republic
of Ireland. Two years earlier, it pulled out of Northern
Ireland, selling its 30-per-cent interest in Ulster
Television. The Aspers' attempt to gain a foothold
in Israel, with the late 2004 purchase of the long-coveted
Jerusalem Post from battered media baron Black, was
thwarted when an international arbitrator ruled in
2006 that they had failed to conclude phase two of
an agreement that would have given them 50-per-cent
ownership.
The late patriarch of the Asper family, "Izzy" Asper had been gradually withdrawing from day-to day running of
his empire for several years. Until his death Oct. 7, 2003,
he remained chairman of the board and the visionary behind
the CanWest Global enterprise. Especially in his home town
of Winnipeg, the self-made billionaire had a reputation as
a major philanthropist as well as a hard-nosed employer.
Taken together, the Asper family owns 40-45 per cent
of CanWest Global and retains outright voting control
of the corporation.
Leonard Asper
The current President and Chief Executive
Officer has had a relatively low profile with rank-and-file
CanWest employees.
To the extent he has cut a public figure,
he has followed with dad's foot-in-mouth style of media
criticism. He has denounced many of the world's journalists – some
by name – as doctrinaire socialists or Marxists with
an anti-Israel bias.
He also has particular requirements of those who would practise
journalism in the name of CanWest Global: "Media
proprietors and managers must ensure that the people
they hire do not bring their ideology into their newsrooms."
CanWest believes different
rules apply to owners:
"Owners have every right to direct their
operations in terms of both content and ideology." — Gordon
Fisher, CanWest's president for news and information
David Asper
CanWest executive vice-president.
The elder Asper brother is now the family's most public
face and infamous
for alienating CanWest employees who dared criticize
the decision to impose national editorials. Calling them "bleeding
hearts" and "riff raff," he accused them of
engaging in "pathetic politics" and "childish
protest" and challenged them to quit and start their
own newspapers.
In the same speech, he chortled, paraphrasing rock
group REM, that the Asper ascension meant "the end of the
world as they know it ... and I feel fine."
David Asper, who had been chairman of CanWest's
publications committee, was named chairman of the National
Post in the spring of 2003, at which point he resigned as
trustee of the right-wing Fraser
Institute. Editor-in-chief Ken Whyte and deputy editor
Martin Newland, who had built the paper into a credible or
at least well-written right-wing voice, were summarily fired.
Respected columnist Paul Wells quit, leading a stampede that
would include David Frum, Mark Steyn and eventually Christie
Blatchford.
Gail Asper
The only one of Izzy's three children
whose involvement in the media empire as director and
corporate secretary is below the public radar. Said
to have a passion for fundraising, Gail Asper is president
of the CanWest Global Foundation and managing
director and secretary of the Asper Foundation, the
private charitable organization spearheading the establishment
of the $300-million Canadian Museum for Human Rights
to be built in Winnipeg.
Derek Burney
The Asper brothers' ties
to the federal Conservative Party were strengthened
Aug. 30, 2006, with the appointment of Derek Burney,
66, as chairman of the CanWest Global Board of Directors.
The former chairman and CEO of Bell Canada International
had earlier in the year served as a backroom organizer,
helping set up Prime Minister Stephen Harper's transition
to power. Burney had served as chief of staff under
Brian Mulroney from 1987 to 1989, and then as Canada's
ambassador to Washington until 1993, when Jean Chrétien's
Liberals swept back into office.
With the death
of the staunchly Liberal Izzy Asper in October 2003,
the chairmanship passed to Frank McKenna, the former
premier of New Brunswick. He resigned in March 2005
to take up the post of Canadian ambassador to the
U.S., which he relinquished when Harper's Conservatives
were elected in January 2006. David Drybrough, a chartered
accountant and Winnipeg native, was named interim
chairman when McKenna departed.
Murdoch Davis
No longer with CanWest. Was editorial
vice-president of CanWest newspapers from summer 2001
to spring 2003.
Davis wrote many or most of CanWest's controversial
national editorials. As the company's senior operating executive
for newspapers, Davis proved a pugnacious
defender of centralized opinion formation.
"Traditionally when a new (proprietor)
took over a newspaper, if they wanted to influence what was
said in the editorials they basically, you know, shot the
editor and got a new one," he told a New York radio
station. "I think we've taken a much more open and above-board
approach."
Davis left CanWest abruptly in May 2003 and
was named publisher of the Winnipeg Free Press, one of the
few large Canadian newspapers not under CanWest control.
Why
should any of this worry journalists,
much less the Canadian
public?
Concentration
of operations
CanWest
Global has adopted an aggressive policy of centralizing
customer service, payroll, accounts payable, information
technology, marketing and other jobs at its corporate head
office and at its Reach Canada arm in Winnipeg, Manitoba.
Advertising work is being directed to CanWest Media Sales,
whose operations are located largely in Toronto, Ontario.
Reader Sales & Service jobs have been moved to Winnipeg
from daily newspapers in Vancouver, Edmonton, Calgary,
Regina, Ottawa and elsewhere.
This strategy
kills jobs in communities across the country. It forces
people in a broad array of newspaper careers to seek new
employment in tight markets and, in many cases, forces
them out of the media industry. The job toll across Canada
was in the hundreds by 2004 and the company continues its
drive to centralize.
The company's
operations in Winnipeg and Toronto are not unionized. CanWest
is not particularly union-friendly. The focus on a low-wage,
replaceable workforce means young people can no longer
consider some of these positions as possible lifelong careers.
While CanWest
can always be counted on to campaign in its newspapers
against the values traditionally championed by the NDP,
it hasn’t hesitated to pocket subsidies
from Gary Doer’s NDP government in Manitoba and from
the City of Winnipeg.
Centralized control
of editorial content
An early example
was the attempt to force CanWest’s major daily newspapers
to run identical national editorials up to three times
a week. This plan has been shelved, whether temporarily
or permanently remains to be seen, in the face of universal scorn
and resistance from CanWest staff, other journalists and
the public.
National editorials were just a harbinger of a deep
corporate drive to squeeze more money from operations,
while simultaneously setting the public agenda. Early
in 2003, the Canada News Desk was established at corporate
headquarters. It rewrites and recirculates copy among CanWest
daily newspapers. Increasingly it is used as the distribution
point for news stories and columns produced under CanWest’s
direct control for publication in its newspapers across
the country — often in place of local writers.
CanWest has created
national critics, whose work is easier to control and direct.
Local critics at major metropolitan newspapers are being
eliminated.
An early example
is TV criticism. CanWest newspapers are being ordered to
run more 'one-view-for-all’ news and criticism rather
than material from local reporters and columnists, the
Canadian Press or other sources. This material is to run
regardless of quality, speed of delivery or diversity.
The effect is
to hollow out local newspapers. The consequences, on quality,
reader choice and freedom of expression, have become all
too clear. If this approach is not arrested, the effects
are likely to worsen and may at some point become irreversible
because of readership declines.
Ambitious goals
So
far, CanWest has no U.S. stations or publications. (It
did own Fireworks, a movie and television distributor that
proved to be a financial sinkhole. It was deep-sixed in
April 2004. Characteristically, the Asper papers put a positive
spin on the story.) CanWest did file a brief with the
Federal Communications Commission in the United States
(the American version of the Canadian Radio-television
and Telecommunications Commission) arguing in favour of
the controversial loosening of cross-media ownership rules.
These rules have already been gutted in Canada but there
is still a battle over the issue south of the border.
The U.S. market
could be next on the CanWest wish list. It has also made
modest forays into radio.
The company’s actions and increasingly visible corporate
agenda have attracted critical attention not just across
Canada, but around the world:
United States
"Quick: What is Canada's leading media company? You
may not have heard much about CanWest Global Communications,
but given the company's recent stunning growth and troubling
behavior, you soon may."
Columbia
Journalism Review
Europe
Newspapers now
controlled by CanWest “were used to substantial editorial
independence before the Aspers took control,” said
The
Economist, a highly respected British publication. “Canada
is a country of several distinct regions. But ownership of
its media is now highly concentrated. And nobody has as much
control over what Canadians read and watch as the Aspers.”
Pacific Region
"Stephen
Kimber, who quit his job as a columnist for the Halifax
Daily News, which is an Asper paper in Halifax, Nova Scotia,
Canada ... appeared earlier today at the cross media hearings
in Canberra, after being brought to Australia by the 'Friends
of Fairfax' group. His message was simple: Before you change
your media ownesrhip laws you better look at what happened
in Canada."
Lateline
/ Australian Broadcasting Corporation
Global
The International
Federation of Journalists, which represents more than 500,000
media professionals in more than 100 countries, has also
spoken out repeatedly, condemning
CanWest’s “corporate censorship and the victimization
of journalists who are trying to defend professional standards.”