23 March 2004

Reporter settles 2-year dispute
with Irving newspaper

Moncton Typographical Union | TNG Canada Local 30636

Photo: Dave Francis

Nobody, regardless of their wealth or power, has the right to inflict damage on others.

Dave Francis
Former reporter

A reporter whose grievance arbitration exposed "outrageous" and "sinister" management conduct at an Irving-owned New Brunswick daily has departed the paper after winning a financial settlement.

Dave Francis, who in December was awarded both aggravated and punitive damages for harassment and mental suffering, was also compensated for the short- and long-term benefits denied him after he took sick leave from the Moncton Times & Transcript in the fall of 2001.

As part of the deal, the Irving family, which has a near-monopoly on newspapers in the province, agreed to forgo a judicial review of the arbitrator's ruling. In turn, Francis has dropped a civil law suit against Canada Life, the company's insurer that refused to pay his long-term benefits.

The arbitrator's ruling, termed a "stinging rebuke of the Irvings," stands as a public record of how the powerful industrialist family deals with workers who don't meekly submit to the company's authority.

March 23/04
Resolute for 7 months, daily's workers get deal


Dec. 27/03
Arbitrator's awards to reporter a 'stinging rebuke of Irvings'


Dec. 24/03
Shrinking Local draws a firm line on further downsizing


Sept. 9/03
Showdown in Moncton: Contract proposal turns pacifists into 'angry mob'

TNG Canada/CWA Rep David Esposti says a "window of opportunity" to achieve a settlement for Francis arose during the seven months of contract talks that produced an agreement the union Local decided to accept.

"I see the settlement as a victory for the little guy even though, of course, the settlement stipulates it is in no way an admission of wrongdoing," says Francis.

"I hope my actions will help others if they must fight similar battles of their own. Nobody, regardless of their wealth or power, has the right to inflict damage on others. Not even the Irvings or the people they hire," he adds.